Understanding your Fixed Price Building Contract in the Construction Industry (2023)

Key Takeaways

  1. Fixed Price Building Contracts are agreements where the contractor commits to complete a project for a predetermined fixed price.
  2. These contracts are beneficial for price predictability and are best suited for projects with well-defined scopes.
  3. Contractors might include a buffer in the initial cost to protect against overruns, which can make these contracts more expensive upfront.
  4. There is a risk of lower quality of work as contractors might cut corners to save costs.
  5. Contractual clauses such as rise and fall clauses, prime costs, and provision sums can allow for certain price adjustments.
  6. Legal advice is crucial before engaging in negotiations or making contractual changes.
  7. Contractors should manage costs effectively and communicate openly with project owners.
  8. Project owners should be vigilant in monitoring progress and should communicate expectations and concerns.
  9. Regular progress meetings between the contractor and project owner can be beneficial.
  10. Understanding the contractual terms and engaging legal counsel is essential for both contractors and project owners.

By being informed and taking a proactive approach, both parties can work towards a successful project completion while navigating the complexities of Fixed Price Building Contracts.

Introduction

Fixed Price Building Contracts are prevalent in the construction industry. These contracts involve an agreement where the contractor is obliged to complete a project for a fixed price. However, the intricacies of these contracts can be daunting. This article aims to provide a comprehensive guide to understanding Fixed Price Building Contracts, their legal aspects, and practical advice for both contractors and project owners.

Understanding Fixed Price Building Contracts

Definition and Basic Concept

Fixed Price Building Contracts, often referred to as lump sum or fixed sum contracts, are agreements where the contractor commits to execute a project for a predetermined fixed price. This type of contract is common in the construction industry, particularly in Construct Only and Design and Construct Contracts.

Benefits of Fixed Price Building Contracts

One of the primary advantages of Fixed Price Building Contracts is price predictability for project owners. Since the price is fixed, project owners can budget effectively. This is particularly beneficial for projects with well-defined scopes where the project owner desires price certainty.

Drawbacks and Risks

However, Fixed Price Building Contracts can have higher initial costs as contractors might include a buffer to safeguard themselves against potential cost overruns. Additionally, there is a risk of lower quality of work as contractors might adopt cost-saving measures to maximize their profit margin.

In my experience...

It is essential for project owners to meticulously review the contract and ensure that it includes clauses that maintain the quality of work. Engaging a Construction Lawyer for Contract Review is definitely recommended.

Discover the differences between Fixed Price Contracts and Contracts with Escalation Clauses / Rise and Fall Clauses

Legal Aspects of Fixed Price Building Contracts

Contractual Clauses

Fixed Price Building Contracts may contain clauses that allow for certain price adjustments. These include rise and fall clauses, prime costs, provision sums, and special conditions. Understanding these clauses is critical for both contractors and project owners.

Rise and Fall Clauses

These clauses allow the contractor to pass on price rises or offer discounts for any reductions. However, for a rise and fall clause to be enforceable, it must not be unconscionable or unreasonable, must be certain, and must be workable.

Prime Cost Items

Prime cost items are fixtures or fittings that have not been selected or whose price is unknown at the time of entering into the building contract. These items usually have an allowance contained in the building contract.

In my experience...

As a contractor, it is vital to communicate clearly with the project owner regarding any allowances for prime cost items. As a project owner, ensure that you understand these allowances and how they might affect the final cost.

Legal Advice and Negotiations

Before engaging in negotiations regarding price increases or any contractual changes, it is imperative to seek legal advice. This is crucial for both contractors and project owners to avoid inadvertently breaching the contract.

In my experience...

I have observed that negotiations without legal advice can lead to disputes and potential litigation. It is advisable to consult a construction lawyer to understand the legalities involved.

Practical Advice for Contractors

Managing Costs

Contractors should be vigilant in managing costs and ensuring that the quality of work is not compromised. It is important to have a clear understanding of the contract terms and conditions.

In my experience...

As a contractor, always ensure that your cost estimates are accurate and include a reasonable buffer for unforeseen expenses. Communicate openly with the project owner regarding any potential changes or challenges.

Practical Advice for Project Owners

Vigilance and Communication

Project owners should be vigilant in monitoring the progress of the project. Open communication with the contractor regarding expectations and any concerns is essential.

In my experience...

As a project owner, establishing regular progress meetings with the contractor canbe instrumental in ensuring that the project stays on track. It’s also important to have a clear understanding of the contractual terms, especially those that could affect the final cost.

Conclusion

Fixed Price Building Contracts can offer a range of benefits, including cost predictability and streamlined budgeting. However, they come with their own set of challenges and complexities. Both contractors and project owners must approach these contracts with diligence and a clear understanding of the terms and conditions. Engaging legal counsel for contract review and negotiations is highly recommended. Open communication and vigilance throughout the project are key to ensuring a successful outcome.

FAQs

1. What is a Fixed Price Building Contract?

A Fixed Price Building Contract is an agreement in which a contractor commits to completing a construction project for a predetermined fixed price. This price includes all materials and labor, and, subject to a few exceptions, cannot be changed.

2. Can a builder increase the price in a Fixed Price Building Contract?

Generally, a builder cannot increase the price in a Fixed Price Building Contract unless there are specific contractual provisions that allow for it, such as rise and fall clauses, prime costs, provision sums, or special conditions.

3. What are rise and fall clauses in a building contract?

Rise and fall clauses, sometimes referred to as cost escalation or price adjustment clauses, allow the builder to pass on any price rises or offer discounts for any reductions. These clauses must be certain, workable, and not unconscionable or unreasonable to be enforceable.

4. What are prime cost items in a building contract?

Prime cost items are fixtures or fittings that have not been selected or whose price is unknown at the time of entering into the building contract. An allowance is usually included in the contract for these items.

5. Can a builder charge more than the initial quote?

A builder can only charge more than the initial quote if there are allowances in the building contract that permit it. Otherwise, unless it is reasonable, a builder cannot charge more than the quote for building works.

6. How can a rise and fall cost adjustment be made?

There are two types of rise and fall clauses: formula-based and cost-based. A formula-based rise and fall clause is calculated using a formula, such as $ per square meter. A cost-based rise and fall clause makes reference to a cost variation.

7. What should I do if my builder is trying to increase the price?

If your builder is trying to increase the price in a Fixed Price Building Contract, it is vital to seek legal advice as soon as possible. Understanding the terms of your contract and consulting a construction lawyer can help you navigate this situation.

8. Are Fixed Price Building Contracts more expensive than other types of contracts?

Fixed Price Building Contracts can be more expensive upfront because contractors often include a buffer to protect against unforeseen costs. However, they offer price predictability, which can be beneficial for budgeting purposes.

9. How long will the building material shortage last?

The building material shortage is influenced by various factors including global events, natural disasters, and economic conditions. It is difficult to predict the exact duration, but it is expected to continue for some time.

10. What should I consider before entering into a Fixed Price Building Contract?

Before entering into a Fixed Price Building Contract, it is important to understand the terms and conditions, review the allowances for prime cost items, be aware of any rise and fall clauses, and seek legal advice. Open communication with the contractor regarding expectations and any concerns is also essential.

Let's chat about how we can
help your business

Rachelle Hare and Shannon Drew, Blaze Business & Legal
  • Free Initial Consultation
  • No-Obligation Quote for our Services
  • We Work to your Budget and Timeframes

Call Rachelle Hare on 0407 050 907 or fill out the form below and we'll contact you

Not quite ready to chat?

Take our free Business Quiz

  • Identify some of the challenges in your Business (you know, the problems that are stressing you out all the time!)
  • Get no-obligation suggestions from us about how you can overcome those challenges (and we will help you implement the fixes as well)

About the Author

Rachelle Hare

Rachelle Hare

Rachelle Hare is a highly experienced Construction Lawyer and Contract Lawyer, with over 23 years of experience in Tier 1 and Tier 2 Construction Firms, Top Tier Private Practice and Government.

With 23+ years of experience as a Senior Lawyer, Strategic Contracting Adviser and Management Consultant in Construction Law, Contracts, Major Projects, Commercial Advisory, Compliance, Procurement, Contract Management and Risk Management, Rachelle has the rare skills to offer you seamless business advice and legal advice to help support your organisation.


As well as a Lawyer and Business Adviser, Rachelle has also acted as a Strategic Procurement Adviser, Compliance Manager, Strategic Risk Adviser and Commercial Manager.

Rachelle owns
Blaze Business & Legal, a combined Commercial Law Firm and Business Advisory Firm located in Brisbane, Queensland, Australia. Blaze Business & Legal assists a broad range of clients in the Construction Industry and related industries, and advises owners, contractors, subcontractors, NFPs and other organisations on a broad range of Construction Law, Commercial Law, Business Advisory and Management Consulting issues in Brisbane, Queensland and around Australia.

Rachelle also owns Blaze Professional Learning, where she offers practical contracting skills, hands-on experience in drafting and working with contracts, and industry insights to help Professionals upskill and advance their careers with real-world skills.

Leave a Comment

Scroll to Top