Indemnities, Insurances and Limits of Liability in Construction Contracts

Indemnities, insurance, and limits of liability are crucial components of any contract. These provisions are designed to protect parties from potential losses or damages that may arise during the course of a business transaction. Understanding these concepts is essential for anyone involved in drafting, negotiating, or reviewing contracts.


Indemnity clauses are promises made by one party to compensate the other party for any losses or damages that may arise from a specific event or circumstance. Insurance provisions, on the other hand, require one or both parties to obtain insurance coverage to protect against potential losses. Limits of liability provisions limit the amount of damages that one party can be held liable for in the event of a breach of contract or other wrongdoing.


In this article, we will provide an overview of indemnities, insurance, and limits of liability, including the principles of insurance, types of indemnity clauses, and how to draft effective clauses. We will also discuss how these provisions work together and how to negotiate and properly draft insurance carveouts and limitations of liability clauses. By the end of this article, you will have a better understanding of these important contract provisions and how to use them to protect your business interests.


Key Takeaways

  • Indemnities are agreements where one party agrees to compensate another party for any losses or damages that may occur. It is important to carefully review the terms of an indemnity agreement before signing it.
  • Indemnity clauses promise to compensate a party for losses or damages that may arise from a specific event or circumstance.
  • Insurance is a way to transfer the risk of loss from one party to another. There are different types of insurance policies available, and it is important to choose the right one for your needs.
  • Insurance provisions require one or both parties to obtain insurance coverage to protect against potential losses.
  • Limits of liability are the maximum amount that a party is responsible for in the event of a loss or damage. It is important to understand the limits of liability in any agreement or insurance policy to ensure that you are adequately protected.
  • Limits of liability provisions limit the amount of damages that one party can be held liable for in the event of a breach of contract or other wrongdoing.
  • When negotiating indemnities, insurance, and limits of liability, it is important to be clear and specific about the terms and conditions. This can help avoid misunderstandings and disputes in the future.
  • It is also important to regularly review and update your insurance policies and indemnity agreements to ensure that they remain relevant and effective.

By understanding these key concepts, you can better protect yourself and your business from potential losses and damages.


Overview of Indemnities

Indemnities are important mechanisms to protect businesses and individuals from financial loss.


An indemnity is a legal agreement where one party agrees to compensate another party for any loss or damage that may arise from a specific event or circumstance. In the context of insurance, indemnities are often used to transfer risk from one party to another.


Indemnities can take many forms, including contractual indemnities, statutory indemnities, and common law indemnities. The type of indemnity used will depend on the specific circumstances of the situation. For example, a contractual indemnity may be used in a construction contract to transfer the risk of property damage from the property owner to the contractor.


It is important to note that indemnities are not the same as insurance. While insurance provides financial protection against a range of risks, indemnities are specific agreements between parties to transfer risk for a particular event or circumstance. However, indemnities are often used in conjunction with insurance policies to provide additional protection.


Overall, indemnities are an important part of contracting. By understanding the different types of indemnities and how they can be used, you can make sure you are not caught out by these provisions and can use them as a part of your risk management strategy (or at least understand the risks they pose for your business).


Principles of Insurance

Insurance is a contract between the insurer and the insured, where the insurer agrees to compensate the insured for any loss or damage caused by an unforeseen event in return for a premium payment.


There are four principles of insurance that are essential to understand:


1. Utmost Good Faith

The principle of utmost good faith requires both the insurer and the insured to be honest and transparent in their dealings with each other. The insurer must disclose all relevant information to the insured, and the insured must provide accurate information about the risk being insured.


2. Insurable Interest

The principle of insurable interest states that the insured must have a financial interest in the property or event being insured. This means that the insured must suffer a financial loss if the insured property is damaged or destroyed.


3. Indemnity

The principle of indemnity states that the insured should be compensated for the actual loss suffered, but not more than the actual loss. This means that the insured cannot profit from an insurance claim.


4. Contribution

The principle of contribution requires that if there are multiple insurance policies covering the same risk, each insurer must contribute proportionally to the loss.


Understanding these principles is crucial when selecting an insurance policy and making a claim. It is important to read and understand the terms and conditions of the policy and to disclose all relevant information to the insurer. And it's essential that you understand any contract dealing with obligations on your business to be insured or your businesses' rights to claim under insurance policies of the other parties.


Overview of Limits of Liability

Limits of liability are a contractual concept where a limit is placed on the amount a party can claim in relation to a certain issue or event, or class of issues/events, under the contract. An example of a limit of liability, also called a limitation of liability, is where a Contractor's ability to claim for anything in relation to a breach of the contract by the Principal is limited to $1 million.


Limitation of Liability clauses often contain provisions which govern how they are to operate. It is important that the parties make sure they understand how the clause works, and that it has been drafted well and so it captures the intent of the parties.


Limitation of Liability clauses often contain carveouts, which allow the Contractor (which is usually the party limited in their claims) to have unlimited claims in certain defined circumstances. A common example is for death or injury to persons, or loss of or damage to property. 


A common limit on the ability of a Contractor to claim under the contract is the limit to the value of an insurance policy. This provision operates to allow a Contractor to claim where an issue or event causes a liabililty and is insured, to the extent that the insurance is paid out under the insurance policy. Otherwise, the Contractor commonly would not be able to claim.


When drafting a construction contract and considering limits of liability, you will need to think about the potential risks and losses that your business could face. And you will want to prevent the Contractor from claiming except in clearly-defined circumstances.


When you're the Contractor who is reviewing a draft contract, you will want to make sure that your insurance coverage is adequate to protect you in the event of a catastrophic event. You will also want to make sure that the ultimate limit or cap on liability is high enough to allow you to claim for common issues/events, and that there are carveouts from the limitation of liability clause that allow you to claim in various circumstances (and particularly where there was a breach by the Principal).


Indemnity Clauses

Types of Indemnity Clauses

Indemnity clauses are a common feature of contracts, particularly in the construction industry. They are designed to allocate risk between the parties to the contract, and provide protection against loss or damage. There are three main types of indemnity clauses: Broad Form Indemnities, Intermediate Form Indemnities, and Limited Form Indemnities.


Broad Form Indemnities

Broad Form Indemnities are the most comprehensive type of indemnity clause. They provide protection to the indemnified party against all claims, losses, and damages arising out of the contract, regardless of fault. This means that the indemnifying party is responsible for any loss or damage, even if it is caused by the indemnified party's own negligence.


Intermediate Form Indemnities

Intermediate Form Indemnities are less comprehensive than Broad Form Indemnities, but more comprehensive than Limited Form Indemnities. They provide protection to the indemnified party against claims, losses, and damages arising out of the contract, but only to the extent that they are caused by the indemnifying party's negligence or breach of contract.


Limited Form Indemnities

Limited Form Indemnities are the least comprehensive type of indemnity clause. They provide protection to the indemnified party against claims, losses, and damages arising out of the contract, but only to the extent that they are caused by the indemnifying party's negligence. They do not provide protection against losses or damages that are caused by the indemnified party's own negligence.


In summary, the type of indemnity clause used in a contract will depend on the level of risk that each party is willing to accept. Broad Form Indemnities provide the most protection, but they also impose the greatest risk on the indemnifying party. Limited Form Indemnities provide the least protection, but they also impose the least risk on the indemnifying party. Intermediate Form Indemnities strike a balance between these two extremes, providing protection to the indemnified party while also limiting the indemnifying party's exposure to risk.


Exclusions/Carveouts from Indemnities

As a general rule, indemnities provide broad protection to the indemnified party against losses arising from a specific event or circumstance.


However, there are certain exclusions or carveouts from indemnities that limit their scope and applicability. These exclusions typically fall into two categories: "known risks" and "third-party claims."


Known risks refer to risks that the indemnified party is aware of or should be aware of at the time the indemnity is given. In such cases, the indemnified party may not be entitled to indemnification for losses arising from those known risks. For example, if a contractor is indemnified for losses arising from a construction project, but the contractor is aware of a particular design flaw in the project, the indemnity may not cover losses arising from that flaw.


Third-party claims refer to claims brought against the indemnified party by someone other than the indemnifying party. In such cases, the indemnifying party may not be required to indemnify the indemnified party for losses arising from those third-party claims. For example, if a company is indemnified for losses arising from a breach of contract, but the breach results in a lawsuit by a third party, the indemnity may not cover losses arising from that lawsuit.


It is important to carefully review the indemnity provisions of any agreement to understand the scope of the indemnity and any exclusions or carveouts that may limit its applicability. In addition, it is important to ensure that appropriate insurance coverage is in place to cover any losses that may not be covered by the indemnity.


Insurance Policy Coverage

As a business owner, it is essential to have insurance coverage to protect your company from potential risks and liabilities. Insurance policies provide financial protection in case of accidents, injuries, or damages that may occur during the course of business operations. In this section, I will discuss the different types of insurance policies that businesses can consider.


1. Public Liability Policies

General liability policies are designed to protect businesses from claims of bodily injury, property damage, or personal injury caused by the company's operations, products, or services. This type of policy can cover legal fees, medical expenses, and other costs associated with a lawsuit.


2. Professional Indemnity Policies

Professional indemnity policies are tailored for businesses that provide professional services such as legal, accounting, or consulting services. This type of policy can cover claims of negligence, errors, or omissions that may arise from the services provided by the business.


3. Construction Works Policies

Construction works policies provide coverage for contractors and builders who are engaged in construction projects. This type of policy can cover damages to the property under construction, injuries to workers, and other risks associated with the construction industry.


4. Product Liability Insurance

Product liability insurance provides coverage for businesses that manufacture or sell products. This type of policy can cover claims of injuries or damages caused by the products sold by the business.


5. Transport Insurance

Transport insurance provides coverage for businesses involved in the transportation of goods or people. This type of policy can cover damages to the goods being transported, injuries to passengers, and other risks associated with transportation.


In conclusion, insurance policies are an essential aspect of risk management for businesses. It is important to choose the right type of policy that suits your business needs and provides adequate coverage. By having insurance coverage, businesses can protect themselves from potential financial losses and liabilities.


How Insurance Provisions work with Indemnity Provisions

When drafting contracts, it's essential to consider both indemnity and insurance provisions. Indemnity provisions require one party to compensate the other party for any losses or damages arising from a specific event. Insurance provisions, on the other hand, require one party to obtain insurance coverage to protect against those losses or damages.


The interaction between indemnity and insurance provisions is critical. Insurance can help limit the indemnitor's exposure by providing a source of funds to pay for any indemnifiable losses. Conversely, indemnity provisions can help ensure that the indemnitor has a financial interest in obtaining insurance coverage.


When drafting indemnity and insurance provisions, it's important to consider the limits of liability. Limits of liability provisions limit the amount of damages that one party can recover from the other party. These provisions are essential to ensure that the indemnitor's exposure is limited to a reasonable amount.


It's also important to consider the scope of the indemnity provision. The scope of the indemnity provision should be limited to the losses or damages that are directly related to the event that triggers the indemnity obligation. This limitation helps ensure that the indemnity provision is not overly broad and that the indemnitor's exposure is limited to the losses or damages that are directly related to the event that triggers the indemnity obligation.


When reviewing indemnity and insurance provisions, it's important to consider the limits of liability, the scope of the indemnity provision, and the interaction between indemnity and insurance provisions. By carefully considering these factors, parties can ensure that their contracts provide adequate protection against losses and damages.


Understanding Limitations of Liability in a Contract

1. Statutory Limits


As a contracting party, it is important to understand the limitations of liability that are imposed by law. In Australia, there are statutory limits on liability that apply to certain types of contracts, such as consumer contracts and contracts for the supply of goods and services. These limits are designed to protect consumers and ensure that they are not unfairly disadvantaged in contractual negotiations.


For example, under the Australian Consumer Law, a supplier of goods or services cannot exclude, restrict or modify their liability for certain types of loss or damage, such as personal injury or death. Similarly, in some states, there are limitations on the amount of damages that can be claimed for personal injury or property damage.


2. Contractual Limits

In addition to statutory limits, parties to a contract may also agree to limit their liability through contractual provisions. These provisions are typically included in the contract and may take the form of indemnities, insurance, or caps on liability.


Indemnities are contractual provisions that require one party to compensate the other party for losses or damages that arise from a particular event or circumstance. For example, a construction contract may include an indemnity clause that requires the contractor to indemnify the owner for any losses or damages that arise from the contractor's negligence.


Insurance is another way that parties can limit their liability. By taking out insurance, a party can transfer the risk of loss or damage to an insurer, who will then be responsible for paying any claims that arise.


Finally, parties may also agree to caps on liability, which limit the amount of damages that can be claimed in the event of a breach of contract. For example, a software licensing agreement may include a cap on liability that limits the software provider's liability to the amount of fees paid by the licensee.


Understanding the limitations of liability in a contract is crucial for all contracting parties. By understanding the statutory limits that apply and the various contractual provisions that can be used to limit liability, parties can negotiate contracts that are fair and balanced.


How Limitations of Liability Provisions fit with Indemnity and Insurance Provisions

Indemnities, insurance provisions, and limitations of liability provisions are included in most contracts. 


These provisions serve different purposes but are often interconnected. In this section, we will discuss how limitations of liability provisions fit with indemnity and insurance provisions.


Indemnity provisions are contractual agreements where one party agrees to compensate the other party for any losses or damages that may arise from a particular event or circumstance. On the other hand, insurance provisions provide coverage against potential losses or damages. These provisions are usually included in contracts to protect parties from financial risks.


Limitations of liability provisions, on the other hand, are clauses that limit the amount of liability that one party can be held responsible for. These provisions are often included in contracts to protect parties from excessive financial exposure.


When it comes to indemnity and insurance provisions, limitations of liability provisions can impact the extent of coverage provided. For example, if a limitation of liability provision is included in a contract, the insurance coverage may only apply up to a certain amount. This means that if the damages exceed the limit, the indemnifying party may be responsible for the excess amount.


Furthermore, limitations of liability provisions can impact the effectiveness of indemnity provisions. If the limitation of liability provision is too restrictive, it may limit the indemnifying party's ability to fully compensate the other party for losses or damages. In such cases, the indemnifying party may not be able to fully meet its contractual obligations.


In conclusion, limitations of liability provisions are an important consideration when drafting indemnity and insurance provisions. It is essential to ensure that these provisions are carefully crafted to avoid any conflicts or misunderstandings that may arise.


Drafting Effective Clauses

When it comes to drafting indemnity, insurance, and limits of liability clauses, it is important to be clear and concise in your language. Ambiguity can lead to confusion and disputes down the line, so make sure you carefully consider the wording of these provisions.


One effective way to ensure clarity is to use defined terms throughout the clause. For example, instead of repeatedly referring to "the indemnifying party" and "the indemnified party," you could define these terms at the beginning of the clause and use them consistently throughout. This can help avoid confusion and ensure that everyone understands their respective obligations.


It is also important to consider the scope of the indemnity. A broad indemnity may seem attractive, but it can also be risky if the indemnifying party is not fully aware of what they are agreeing to cover. On the other hand, a narrow indemnity may not provide sufficient protection. Careful consideration should be given to the scope of the indemnity to ensure that it is both reasonable and effective.


In addition to indemnity clauses, insurance and limits of liability provisions should also be carefully drafted. Insurance requirements should be clearly stated, including the types of insurance required, the amount of coverage, and any specific requirements for the insurance policy itself. Limits of liability should also be clearly stated, with consideration given to any applicable laws and regulations.


Overall, effective drafting of indemnity, insurance, and limits of liability clauses requires careful consideration of the language used, the scope of the provisions, and any applicable laws and regulations. By taking the time to carefully draft these clauses, parties can help ensure that their agreements are clear, effective, and enforceable.


How to Determine the Extent of an Indemnity Clause

As an indemnity clause is a contractual agreement between two parties, it is essential to understand its extent before entering into the agreement. Here are some factors to consider when determining the extent of an indemnity clause:


1. Scope of the Indemnity

The scope of the indemnity clause should be clearly defined. This means that the parties should specify the types of losses, damages, and claims that the indemnifying party is responsible for. The indemnity clause should also specify the circumstances under which the indemnifying party will be liable.


2. Insurance Coverage

It is important to determine whether the indemnifying party has insurance coverage that will cover the losses, damages, and claims specified in the indemnity clause. If the indemnifying party has insurance coverage, the indemnity clause should specify that the insurance coverage will be the primary source of coverage.


3. Limits of Liability

The indemnity clause should specify the limits of liability of the indemnifying party. This means that the parties should agree on the maximum amount that the indemnifying party will be liable for. The indemnity clause should also specify whether the limits of liability apply to each occurrence or to the aggregate of all occurrences.


In summary, determining the extent of an indemnity clause requires a thorough understanding of the scope of the indemnity, insurance coverage, and limits of liability. By considering these factors, the parties can ensure that the indemnity clause is clear, enforceable, and effective in protecting their interests.


How to Negotiate a Limit of Liability Clause

As a business owner, negotiating a limit of liability clause is an important aspect of protecting your company from potential lawsuits. Here are some tips on how to negotiate a limit of liability clause:

  1. Understand the Risks: Before negotiating a limit of liability clause, it is important to understand the risks associated with your business. This will help you determine the appropriate limit of liability that you should negotiate.
  2. Be Clear and Specific: When negotiating a limit of liability clause, it is important to be clear and specific about what is covered under the clause. This will help to avoid any confusion or disputes in the future.
  3. Consider the Other Party's Perspective: When negotiating a limit of liability clause, it is important to consider the other party's perspective. This will help you to understand their concerns and negotiate a fair and reasonable limit of liability.
  4. Use Tables and Lists: To make the negotiation process easier, use tables and lists to clearly outline the terms of the limit of liability clause. This will help to avoid any misunderstandings or misinterpretations.
  5. Seek Legal Advice: It is always a good idea to seek legal advice when negotiating a limit of liability clause. A lawyer can help to ensure that the clause is fair and reasonable, and that it adequately protects your business.

By following these tips, you can negotiate a limit of liability clause that protects your business from potential lawsuits, while also being fair and reasonable for all parties involved.


How to Properly Draft an Insurance Carveout

As a legal professional, I have found that drafting an insurance carveout can be a complex and nuanced process. However, by following a few key steps, you can ensure that your carveout is properly drafted and provides the necessary protection for your client.


Firstly, it is important to clearly define the scope of the carveout. This means identifying the specific risks that are not covered by the insurance policy and ensuring that they are clearly articulated in the carveout. This may involve creating a list of exclusions or limitations that are tailored to the specific circumstances of the transaction.


Secondly, it is important to ensure that the carveout is properly integrated into the overall insurance provisions of the contract. This means ensuring that there is no overlap or ambiguity between the carveout and the other insurance provisions, and that the carveout is consistent with the overall risk allocation of the contract.


Thirdly, it is important to ensure that the carveout is drafted in a clear and unambiguous manner. This means avoiding overly complex or convoluted language, and using clear and concise terms that are easily understood by all parties.


Finally, it is important to ensure that the carveout is properly negotiated and agreed upon by all parties. This means ensuring that the carveout is properly reviewed and approved by all relevant stakeholders, and that any concerns or objections are addressed in a timely and constructive manner.


By following these key steps, you can ensure that your insurance carveout is properly drafted and provides the necessary protection for your client.


Conclusion

In conclusion, indemnities, insurance, and limits of liability are important aspects of any contract. They help to protect both parties from potential risks and losses.


It is crucial to carefully review and negotiate these terms to ensure that they are fair and reasonable for both parties. This includes understanding the scope of the indemnity, the types of insurance required, and the limits of liability that are acceptable.


When negotiating these terms, it is important to consider the specific circumstances of the contract and the potential risks involved. This may require seeking legal or insurance advice to ensure that the terms are appropriate and effective.


Overall, by carefully considering and negotiating indemnities, insurance, and limits of liability, parties can minimize their exposure to risk and ensure that they are protected in the event of any unforeseen circumstances.


Frequently Asked Questions

1. What does a 'liability limited to insurance limits' clause entail?

A liability limited to insurance limits clause is a provision in a contract that restricts the amount of liability to the insurance policy limits. This means that the party responsible for damages or losses will only be liable up to the amount of insurance coverage that they have. If the damages or losses exceed the insurance policy limits, the party responsible will not be held liable for the excess amount.


2. How is the aggregate limit of indemnity determined in an insurance policy?

The aggregate limit of indemnity is the maximum amount that an insurance company will pay out for all claims during the policy period. This limit is determined by the insurance company and is based on factors such as the type of insurance policy, the risk involved, and the amount of coverage requested by the insured party.


3. What are the common stipulations of a liability cap in contractual agreements?

A liability cap is a provision in a contract that limits the amount of liability for damages or losses. Common stipulations of a liability cap include a maximum amount of liability, a restriction on the types of damages or losses that are covered, and a requirement for the party responsible to provide notice of any potential claims.


4. Could you provide an example of a capped indemnity clause?

An example of a capped indemnity clause is: "In no event shall my liability exceed the total amount paid by the client for the services provided."


5. In what ways does an aggregate liability cap clause affect claim settlements?

An aggregate liability cap clause can limit the amount of damages or losses that can be recovered in a claim settlement. This means that if the damages or losses exceed the aggregate limit of indemnity, the party responsible will not be held liable for the excess amount.


6. How does a limitation of liability clause function within Australian contract law?

A limitation of liability clause is generally enforceable under Australian contract law, but it must be reasonable and not unconscionable. The courts will consider factors such as the bargaining power of the parties, the nature of the transaction, and the extent of the limitation when determining the reasonableness of the clause.

Let's chat about how we can help your business

Rachelle Hare and Shannon Drew, Blaze Business & Legal
  • Free Initial Consultation
  • No-Obligation Quote for our Services
  • We Work to your Budget and Timeframes

Call Rachelle Hare on 0407 050 907 or fill out the form below and we'll contact you

Not quite ready to chat?

Take our free Business Quiz

  • Identify some of the challenges in your Business
  • Get no-obligation suggestions from us about how you can overcome those challenges

About the Author

Rachelle Hare

Rachelle Hare - Managing Director and Principal Practitioner of Blaze Business & Legal

Rachelle Hare

Rachelle Hare is a highly experienced Construction Lawyer and Contract Lawyer, with over 23 years of experience in Tier 1 and Tier 2 Construction Firms, Top Tier Private Practice and Government.

With 23+ years of experience as a Senior Lawyer, Strategic Contracting Adviser and Management Consultant in Construction Law, Contracts, Major Projects, Commercial Advisory, Compliance, Procurement, Contract Management and Risk Management, Rachelle has the rare skills to offer you seamless business advice and legal advice to help support your organisation.


As well as a Lawyer and Business Adviser, Rachelle has also acted as a Strategic Procurement Adviser, Compliance Manager, Strategic Risk Adviser and Commercial Manager.

Rachelle owns
Blaze Business & Legal, a combined Commercial Law Firm and Business Advisory Firm located in Brisbane, Queensland, Australia. Blaze Business & Legal assists a broad range of clients in the Construction Industry and related industries, and advises owners, contractors, subcontractors, NFPs and other organisations on a broad range of Construction Law, Commercial Law, Business Advisory and Management Consulting issues in Brisbane, Queensland and around Australia.

Rachelle also owns Blaze Professional Learning, where she offers practical contracting skills, hands-on experience in drafting and working with contracts, and industry insights to help Professionals upskill and advance their careers with real-world skills.

Scroll to Top